Hj. Gross et al., MODEL STUDY DETECTING BREAST-CANCER CELLS IN PERIPHERAL-BLOOD MONONUCLEAR-CELLS AT FREQUENCIES AS LOW AS 10(-7), Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United Statesof America, 92(2), 1995, pp. 537-541
A flow cytometric assay was developed to detect rare cancer cells in b
lood and bone marrow, Multiple markers, each identified by a separate
color of immunofluorescence (yellow and two shades of red), are used t
o reliably identify the cancer cells, Blood or bone marrow cells, whic
h are not of interest but interfere in detecting the cancer cells, are
identified by a panel of immunofluorescence markers, each of which ha
s the same color (green), Thus, the rare cancer cells of interest are
yellow and two different shades of red but not green. The requirement
that the rare cancer cell be simultaneously positive for three separat
e colors (the specific markers) and negative for a fourth color (the e
xclusion color) allowed detection of as few as one cancer cell in 10(7
) nucleated blood cells (a frequency of 10(-7)). To test this rare-eve
nt assay prior to clinical studies, a model study was performed in whi
ch the clinical sample was simulated by mixing small numbers of cells
from the breast carcinoma line BT-20 with peripheral blood mononuclear
cells, We detected statistically significant numbers of BT-20 cells a
t mixing frequencies of 10(-5), 10(-6), and 10(-7), In control samples
, no target events (BT-20) were observed when more than 10(8) cells we
re analyzed, For additional confirmation that the BT-20 cells in the m
odel study were correctly identified and counted, the BT-20 cells (and
only BT-20 cells) were covalently stained with a fifth fluorescent dy
e, 7-amino-4-chloromethylcoumarin (CMAC), CMAC fluorescence data were
not used in the assay for detecting BT-20 cells, Only after the analys
is using data from the specific and exclusion colors had been complete
d were the events identified as BT-20 cells checked for CMAC fluoresce
nce, The putative BT-20 events were always found to be positive for CM
AC fluorescence, which further increases confidence in the assay, Manu
al data analysis and an automated computer program were compared, Resu
lts were comparable with the manual and automated methods, but the aut
omated ''genetic algorithm'' always found more BT-20 events, Cell sort
ing of BT-20 cells from samples that contained BT-20 at frequencies of
10(-5), 10(-6), and 10(-7) provided further evidence that these rare
cells could be reliably detected, The good performance of the assay wi
th the model system will encourage further studies on clinical samples
.