G. Kerstiens et Cv. Hawes, RESPONSE OF GROWTH AND CARBON ALLOCATION TO ELEVATED CO2 IN YOUNG CHERRY (PRUNUS-AVIUM L) SAPLINGS IN RELATION TO ROOT ENVIRONMENT, New phytologist, 128(4), 1994, pp. 607-614
The hypothesis that inadequate rooting volume may reduce the growth st
imulation by elevated CO2 in potted tree seedlings and saplings was te
sted experimentally and by surveying the literature. One-year-old cher
ry saplings were grown for one season in naturally lit growth chambers
in eight combinations of CO2 concentration (ambient; ambient + 250 pp
m) and root environment (four types). The latter included (1) moderate
ly restrictive pot volume (4 l) in combination with two levels of fert
ilizer addition (1a, 1b); (2) 10 l pots with total fertilizer content
per pot as in treatment 1a, and (3) 20 l pots with five plants sharing
five times the space and nutrient resources of treatment 1a. Plants w
ere harvested in April, May, June, August and September. The overall m
ean effect of high CO2 plant dry mass by the end of the season was +24
%. Interactive effects of root environments and CO2 concentrations on
dry mass were not significant at the 5% level, but repeated measuremen
ts of basal stem diameter of individual plants indicated a significant
impact of root environment on the response to CO2. Overall growth enh
ancement by elevated CO2 did not differ significantly between harvests
, but it tended to increase during the season in those root environmen
ts which restricted growth in ambient CO2 most strongly (1a and 3). Th
e hypothesis was rejected for this experiment. Leaf area and stem heig
ht were not affected by any treatment. The variation of carbon allocat
ion to roots and shoots with plant size was very similar in all treatm
ents. Plants grew faster in elevated CO2 very early in the season, and
this resulted in small but significant differences between seasonal p
atterns of biomass partitioning in ambient and elevated CO2. A survey
of 33 studies on growth responses of 47 tree species to elevated CO2 (
600-800 ppm) showed that the relative change in biomass was not relate
d to the ratio of plant biomass and pot volume found in either ambient
or elevated CO2. We conclude that there is no evidence that inadequat
e pot volume had a negative impact on the stimulation of growth of tre
e species in elevated CO2.