ISOTOPIC AND GEOCHEMICAL INVESTIGATION OF THE CHILWA-ISLAND CARBONATITE COMPLEX, MALAWI - EVIDENCE FOR A DEPLETED MANTLE SOURCE REGION, LIQUID IMMISCIBILITY, AND OPEN-SYSTEM BEHAVIOR
A. Simonetti et K. Bell, ISOTOPIC AND GEOCHEMICAL INVESTIGATION OF THE CHILWA-ISLAND CARBONATITE COMPLEX, MALAWI - EVIDENCE FOR A DEPLETED MANTLE SOURCE REGION, LIQUID IMMISCIBILITY, AND OPEN-SYSTEM BEHAVIOR, Journal of Petrology, 35(6), 1994, pp. 1597-1621
Initial Nd, Pb, and Sr isotopic data from carbonatites and associated
intrusive silica-undersaturated rocks from the early Jurassic, Chilwa
Island complex, located in southern Malawi, central Africa, suggest me
lt derivation from a Rb/Sr- and Nd/Sm-depleted but Th/Pb- and U/Pb-enr
iched mantle source. Initial Nd-143/Nd-144 (0.51265-0.51270) isotope r
atios from the Chilwa Island carbonatites are relatively constant, but
their initial Sr-87/Sr-86 (0.70319-0.70361) ratios are variable. The
delta(18)O(SMOW) (9.53-14.15 parts per thousand) and delta(13)C(PDB) (
- 3.27 to - 1.50 parts per thousand) isotope ratios of the carbonates
are enriched relative to the range of mantle values, and there is a ne
gative correlation between delta(18)O and Sr isotope ratios. The varia
tions in Sr, C, and O isotopic ratios from the carbonatites suggest se
condary processes, such as interaction with meteoric groundwater durin
g late-stage carbonatite activity. The initial Nd-143/Nd-144 (0.51246-
0.51269) and initial Sr-87/Sr-86 (0.70344-0.70383) isotope ratios from
the intrusive silicate rocks are more variable, and the Sr more radio
genic than those from the carbonatites. Most of the Pb isotope data fr
om Chilwa Island plot to the right of the geochron and close to the oc
eanic regression line defined by MORBs and OIBs. Initial Pb isotopic r
atios from both carbonatites (Pb-207/Pb-204 15.63-15.71; Pb-206/Pb-204
19.13-19.78) and silicate rocks (Pb-207/Pb-204 15.61-15.72; Pb-206/Pb
-204 18.18-20.12) show pronounced variations, and form two groups in P
b-Pb plots. The isotopic variations shown by Nd, Pb, and Sr for the Ch
ilwa Island carbonatites and intrusive silicates suggest that these me
lts underwent different evolutionary histories. The chemical data, inc
luding isotopic ratios, from the carbonatites and olivine nephelinites
are consistent with magmatic differentiation of a carbonated-nephelin
ite magma. A model is proposed in which differentiation of the carbona
tite magma was accompanied by fenitization (metasomatic alteration) of
the country rocks by carbonatite-derived fluids, and subsequent alter
ation of the carbonatite by hydrothermal activity. The chemical and is
otopic data from the non-nephelinitic intrusive silicate rocks reveal
a more complex evolutionary history, involving either selective binary
mixing of lower-crustal granulites and a nephelinite magma, or increm
ental batch melting of a depleted source and subsequent crustal contam
ination.