Federal law requires that surface-mined prime farmland be reclaimed an
d restored to premining productivity for row crops (Surface Mining Con
trol and Reclamation Act, Public Law 95-87). In Illinois, reclamation
must include soil horizon replacement (topsoil and subsoil) to a depth
of 120 cm. Poor physical condition is the most limiting factor in rec
lamation in Illinois. The effects of five deep tillage implements (80-
120-cm tillage depth) and two standard agricultural chisel plows (20-3
5-cm tillage depth) were evaluated for 6 yr. The seven tillage treatme
nts were applied to a scraper-placed minesoil that had a high soil str
ength (2.5-3.5 MPa) throughout the reconstructed profile. A nearby tra
ct of undisturbed Cisne silt loam (fine, montmorillonitic, mesic Molli
c Albaqualf) was used as a prime farmland comparison. Crop yields for
both corn (Zea mays L.) and soybean [Glycine mar (L.) Merr.] significa
ntly increased with tillage depth. Average soil strength decreased and
net water extraction increased with increasing depth of tillage. The
1.2-m-deep tillage treatments significantly reduced average 23- to 114
-cm soil strength from 2.8 to 0.93 MPa. Significant correlation occurr
ed between 23- to 114-cm average soil strength and 6-yr mean corn (-0.
97* [significant at P = 0.01]) and 4-yr mean soybean (-0.92**) yields
. Deep tillage successfully restored productivity; however, the depth
of tillage necessary was influenced by initial levels of soil strength
.