Mr. Trenerry et al., GENDER DIFFERENCES IN POST-TEMPORAL LOBECTOMY VERBAL MEMORY AND RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN MRI HIPPOCAMPAL VOLUMES AND PREOPERATIVE VERBAL MEMORY, Epilepsy research, 20(1), 1995, pp. 69-76
Thirty-three men and 42 women who underwent left, and 26 men and 24 wo
men who underwent right temporal lobectomy (TL) were studied retrospec
tively to determine if there were sex differences in (1) verbal memory
outcome, and (2) relationships between verbal memory and magnetic res
onance imaging (MRI) hippocampal volumes. All patients were left hemis
phere language dominant. The surgical specimen and MRI were consistent
only with mesial temporal sclerosis (MTS). Verbal memory was evaluate
d by Logical Memory percent retention (LMPER) from the Wechsler Memory
Scale-Revised (WMS-R). Women experienced a significant improvement wh
ile men experienced a significant decline in postoperative LMPER. The
difference between right and left hippocampal volumes predicted verbal
memory outcome in both men and women. Preoperative LMPER was positive
ly correlated with both the left and right hippocampal volumes in left
TL women only. No verbal memory sex differences or correlations betwe
en LMPER and MRI data were found in the right TL group. The data suppo
rt the presence of human neurocognitive sexual dimorphism. Verbal memo
ry abilities supported by the hippocampus are less lateralized in wome
n with left temporal lobe epilepsy and mesial temporal sclerosis. Wome
n appear to have greater verbal memory plasticity following early left
mesial temporal lobe insult.