ACUTE AND SUBLETHAL TOXICITY OF SEEPAGE WATERS FROM GARBAGE DUMPS TO PERMANENT CELL-LINES AND PRIMARY CULTURES OF HEPATOCYTES FROM RAINBOW-TROUT (ONCORHYNCHUS-MYKISS) - A NOVEL-APPROACH TO ENVIRONMENTAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CHEMICALS AND CHEMICAL-MIXTURES
T. Zahn et al., ACUTE AND SUBLETHAL TOXICITY OF SEEPAGE WATERS FROM GARBAGE DUMPS TO PERMANENT CELL-LINES AND PRIMARY CULTURES OF HEPATOCYTES FROM RAINBOW-TROUT (ONCORHYNCHUS-MYKISS) - A NOVEL-APPROACH TO ENVIRONMENTAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CHEMICALS AND CHEMICAL-MIXTURES, Zentralblatt fur Hygiene und Umweltmedizin, 196(5), 1995, pp. 455-479
In order to evaluate the suitability of cytopathological criteria in i
solated fish hepatocytes as endpoints in (eco)toxicological research,
liver cells isolated from rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) by colla
genase perfusion were exposed in vitro for up to 5 days to sublethal d
ilutions of two seepage water samples collected from garbage dumps. He
patocytes were analysed with respect to acute (lactate dehydrogenase l
eakage) and sublethal toxicity (electron microscopy, stereology). In a
ddition, acute toxicity (24 h) was tested in the piscine fibrocytic ce
ll line R1 by means of crystal violet staining and neutral red retenti
on. Acute toxicity in R1 cells and isolated hepatocytes could only be
documented for sample I at dilutions of 1:2 and 1:4. This difference i
n toxicity could be corroborated by cytological alterations in isolate
d hepatocytes, which could be documented for dilutions of 1:100 and 1:
8 in samples I and II, respectively. Ultrastructural changes were time
- and dose-dependent and included reduction of hepatocellular volume,
disturbance of intracellular compartmentation, modified heterochromati
n distribution, transformation of rough endoplasmic reticulum into con
centric membrane whorls, proliferation of lysosomes and cytoplasmic va
cuoles, as well as reduction of hepatocellular glycogen. Although seve
ral hepatocellular reactions were found after exposure to either sampl
e, the syndrom of ultrastructural alterations allowed clear differenti
ation between the two samples. Results illustrate that cytological eff
ects far below macroscopically detectable damage can be discovered not
only in intact fish, but also in fish cell culture systems. On the ba
sis of the data presented, a multi-tiered test procedure for aquatic t
oxicity assessment exclusively based on tests with fish cell culture s
ystems is proposed: (1) rapid screening for acute toxicity with perman
ent cell lines; (2) short-term tests with more complex, yet more sensi
tive systems such as primary hepatocytes with straightforward biochemi
cal endpoints; (3) prolonged exposure of isolated hepatocytes in combi
nation with ultrastructural and biochemical investigations as a sensit
ive tool to detect adverse effects at environmentally relevant toxican
t concentrations.