D. Umbricht et al., POSTICTAL AND CHRONIC PSYCHOSES IN PATIENTS WITH TEMPORAL-LOBE EPILEPSY, The American journal of psychiatry, 152(2), 1995, pp. 224-231
Objective: This study sought to elucidate the relation of clinical, ne
uropsychological, and seizure variables to chronic and postictal psych
oses in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy. Method: Forty-four patie
nts with treatment-refractory temporal lobe epilepsy were given formal
psychiatric evaluations; 29 patients had no psychiatric disorder or a
nonpsychotic disorder, eight patients had postictal psychoses, and se
ven patients had chronic psychoses. Comparisons of clinical, neuropsyc
hological, magnetic resonance imaging, and seizure variables were made
between the nonpsychotic and the psychotic patients and secondarily,
between the patients with transient postictal psychoses and those with
chronic psychoses. Results: Bitemporal seizure foci, clustering of se
izures, and absence of febrile convulsions were associated with both p
ostictal psychoses and chronic psychoses. Younger age at onset of epil
epsy and lower verbal and full-scale IQs differentiated the patients w
ith chronic psychoses from those with postictal psychoses. Conclusions
: Patients with temporal lobe epilepsy with chronic and postictal psyc
hoses show similar profiles of clinical and seizure variables, suggest
ing shared etiologic factors. These factors may increase the propensit
y to develop psychotic symptoms, while other factors, such as time of
onset of epilepsy and underlying neuropathology, may determine whether
transient or chronic psychotic symptoms develop. Even among patients
with treatment-refractory temporal lobe epilepsy, a specific subgroup
of patients, characterized by bitemporal seizure foci, art absence of
febrile convulsions, and a history of clustering of seizures, appears
to be particularly prone to develop psychotic disorders. A process sim
ilar to secondary epileptogenesis may be involved in the development o
f the psychoses.