Objective: The authors compared the effects of bupropion, fluoxetine,
and cognitive behavior therapy on EEG sleep in depressed subjects. Met
hod: All-night sleep EEG studies were performed before treatment and a
fter partial or full remission on 18 men with depression diagnosed acc
ording to Research Diagnostic Criteria and randomly assigned to treatm
ent with either bupropion (N=7) or fluoxetine (N=11). Response to thes
e drugs was measured by changes in Hamilton Depression Rating Scale sc
ores. Pre- and posttreatment EEG sleep study results before and after
treatment with cognitive behavior therapy were also available for 18 m
en matched in age and severity of Hamilton depression scale score, and
one-time EEG sleep measures were available for 36 men who were not de
pressed. Results: REM latency was reduced and REM sleep percent and RE
M time increased after treatment in the depressed men given bupropion.
These effects contrasted with the effects of fluoxetine and cognitive
behavior therapy. Conclusions: This study represents the first report
of an antidepressant medication that shortens REM latency and increas
es REM sleep. If confirmed, this finding may require a revision of our
current understanding of the relation among depression, REM sleep, an
d antidepressant mechanisms.