DIFFERENTIAL CONVERGENCE OF SELF-REPORT AND INFORMANT DATA FOR MULTIDIMENSIONAL PERSONALITY QUESTIONNAIRE TRAITS - IMPLICATIONS FOR THE CONSTRUCT OF NEGATIVE EMOTIONALITY
Ar. Harkness et al., DIFFERENTIAL CONVERGENCE OF SELF-REPORT AND INFORMANT DATA FOR MULTIDIMENSIONAL PERSONALITY QUESTIONNAIRE TRAITS - IMPLICATIONS FOR THE CONSTRUCT OF NEGATIVE EMOTIONALITY, Journal of personality assessment, 64(1), 1995, pp. 185-204
Construct validation work on Tellegen's (1982) Multidimensional Person
ality Questionnaire (MPQ) resulted in further inferences about Negativ
e Emotionality. Two hundred thirty-two students were rated by three kn
owledgeable informants, yielding a total of 928 participants. The medi
an monotrait correlation of MPQ primary scores with summed observer ra
tings was .48, and all were significant, p < .01. These data show high
er self-report to informant rating convergences in the Positive Emotio
nality (Extroversion) domain than in the Negative Emotionality (Neurot
icism) domain. Furthermore, in the Negative Emotionality domain, peers
, mothers, and fathers were not equivalent as classes of raters. Stres
s Reaction ratings showed uniformly lower levels of convergence with s
elf-report (relative to Positive Emotionality traits) across all rater
classes. For Alienation, peer and maternal ratings were comparable, b
ut paternal ratings correlated significantly less with self-report sco
res than did maternal ratings. And finally, with Aggression, peer rati
ngs correlated significantly higher with self-report than either mater
nal or paternal ratings. These findings, taken in the context of the l
iterature, have implications for a hierarchical model of Negative Emot
ionality, support inferences about the display of cues of Negative Emo
tionality, and offer new cautions for rating-based assessment.