Ft. Hoaglund et al., EXTREME VARIATIONS IN RACIAL RATES OF TOTAL HIP-ARTHROPLASTY FOR PRIMARY COXARTHROSIS - A POPULATION-BASED STUDY IN SAN-FRANCISCO, Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases, 54(2), 1995, pp. 107-110
Objectives-To compare the incidence of all total hip arthroplasty, and
total hip arthroplasty for primary coxarthrosis, among the Asian, bla
ck, Hispanic, and white populations living in one locale. Methods-We i
dentified all San Francisco residents who underwent total hip replacem
ents (THR) in the 17 hospitals for or near San Francisco during a five
year period. Preoperative pelvic radiographs were read without prior
knowledge of the gender or race of the subject, to diagnose the specif
ic hip diseases. Age standardised THR incidence by race and gender was
determined, as was the comparative THR incidence for specific diagnos
is (primary and secondary osteoarthritis). Results-The greatest annual
rate of total hip replacement occurred in white women (97 per 100000
population), followed by white men, black women, black men, Hispanic w
omen, and Hispanic men. The smallest numbers were found in Asians, who
se THR rate was 10% that of whites. A primary coxarthrosis greatest am
ong white followed by black Hispanics (53%), and Asians (28%). Age sta
ndardised THR rates for primary coxarthrosis per 100000 population wer
e Likewise greatest among whites (43.0) and least among Asians (1.3 fo
r Chinese). Mean age of patients undergoing THR for primary coxarthros
is was 70 years for white subjects and almost a decade younger in all
other groups. Conclusions-THR rates are much lower for Asians, Hispani
cs, and black subjects than for the white population living in San Fra
ncisco. The low rates of total hip arthrosplasty in the non-white grou
ps was related to the much lower incidence of Honolulu THR for primary
coxarthrosis among non-whites than among whites. The racial distribut
ion of primary coxarthrosis among patients who underwent THR is consis
tent with distribution patterns reported internationally.