EVIDENCE OF A DIRECT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN NEUTROPHIL COLLAGENASE ACTIVITY AND PERIODONTAL TISSUE DESTRUCTION IN-VIVO - ROLE OF ACTIVE ENZYME IN HUMAN PERIODONTITIS
W. Lee et al., EVIDENCE OF A DIRECT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN NEUTROPHIL COLLAGENASE ACTIVITY AND PERIODONTAL TISSUE DESTRUCTION IN-VIVO - ROLE OF ACTIVE ENZYME IN HUMAN PERIODONTITIS, Journal of Periodontal Research, 30(1), 1995, pp. 23-33
To assess the temporal relationship between periodontal tissue destruc
tion and the activity of collagenase, exudate from inflamed periodonta
l tissues was collected and latent and active collagenase activities w
ere measured by a functional assay in a longitudinal cohort study. Com
parisons were made between human subjects with either: 1) inflammation
with a previous history of progressive loss of connective tissue and
bone support (n=14); 2) inflammation and previous history of bone loss
but now clinically stable (n=27); or 3) inflammation and no loss of b
one support (n=17). Experiments using specific enzyme inhibitors, bloc
king antibodies and SDS-PAGE fluorograph to identify the pattern of co
llagen substrate degradation demonstrated that the collagenase activit
y was derived from neutrophils and not from bacteria or other host cel
ls. Active collagenase activity pooled from 6 sites per subject was re
spectively 5 and 6-fold higher in the group with progressive loss of c
onnective tissue compared to the groups with either inflamed tissues a
lone or with inflammation and previous bone loss. In contrast, latent
collagenase was increased up to 2 fold higher in the group with inflam
mation but no bone loss compared to the group with progressive lesions
. Moreover, the ratio of active to total collagenase activity was 50%
higher in the group with progressive lesions. Although in all subjects
successive measurements of site-specific active collagenase I month a
part demonstrated wide variation (r<0.50), only in sites with progress
ive periodontal destruction was there significant increase of active c
ollagenase with time (1.28x10(-4) collagenase units per day). There we
re also sharp elevations in active enzyme level at the time of detecti
on of loss of connective tissue attachment in specific sites of 8 Subj
ects. At the time of detection of connective tissue attachment loss, t
here was an overall 40% increase of pooled active collagenase activity
in all subjects with progressive loss of connective tissue compared t
o pre-breakdown sampling times. These data provide strong in vivo evid
ence for a direct role of active neutrophil collagenase in the patholo
gical destruction of periodontal connective tissue.