In the Purcell anticlinorium of the Canadian Cordillera, prominent upp
er-crustal seismic reflectors and areas of high electrical conductivit
y coincide over a wide area. Reflective layers traceable to outcrop an
d to drill hole are caused mostly by impedance contrasts between Prote
rozoic gabbroic sills and metasedimentary rocks. Layers with high elec
trical conductivity are zones enriched in magnetic sulfide (probably p
yrrhotite) within the sedimentary rocks. Attempts to interpret reflect
ivity and high conductivity in terms of a single geologic process, alt
hough tempting and certainly satisfying by appealing to Ocam's razor,
must be done with care. We speculate that some explanations for crusta
l reflectors and conductors may be unrealistic and propose an alternat
ive paradigm of interlayered sills and (meta) sedimentary rocks rich i
n high-conductivity minerals to explain both.