We have reviewed the results of a pilot study of preschool screening b
y orthoptists for vision defects which was introduced in Newcastle in
1987. We have compared the visual outcomes, at age 7 years, of childre
n who were screened at age 3 years by either orthoptists, health visit
ors or general practitioners in three matched, geographically defined
cohorts. Manifest, large angle strabismus presented at the same age, a
nd in roughly equal numbers in each cohort. Orthoptic screening detect
ed many more cases of amblyopia associated with microtropia and anisom
etropia, but the overall amblyopia prevalence at age 7 years was simil
ar in each cohort. This study does not provide evidence to support the
nationwide introduction of primary orthoptic preschool vision screeni
ng, and highlights the need for a prospective treatment trial of ambly
opia associated with microtropia and anisometropia.