Rectourethral fistulas are a rare but devastating complication of urin
ary or rectal surgery, trauma or inflammation. Historically repair has
posed a challenge because of technical difficulties and the high inci
dence of recurrent fistulas. We report 7 cases of acquired rectourethr
al fistulas of varying etiology (3 after prostatectomy, 3 after trauma
and 1 after recurrent perineal abscess), which were managed by variou
s means. Our data and those in the literature suggest that the first a
ttempt at repair is the best and subsequent repairs become increasingl
y difficult; the York Mason approach allows easy accessibility with mi
nimal risk of complications and the best chance for a functionally suc
cessful outcome when a vascularized flap is not required, and some cas
es may have such a low probability of successful resolution of the fis
tula as well as maintenance of urinary continence that cystectomy and
supravesical diversion are appropriate considerations.