A. Wilcox et al., BIRTH-WEIGHT AND PERINATAL-MORTALITY - A COMPARISON OF THE UNITED-STATES AND NORWAY, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 273(9), 1995, pp. 709-711
Objective.-To compare perinatal mortality in the United States and Nor
way, using a new analytic approach based on relative birth weight. Des
ign.-Comparison of linked birth and perinatal death records for US and
Norwegian births from 1986 through 1987, the most recently available
2-year period. Setting.-Norway and the United States. Participants.-A
total of 7 445 914 US births and 105 084 Norwegian births. Interventio
ns.-None. Main Outcome Measure.-Perinatal weight-specific mortality af
ter adjustment for each country's own mean birth weight. Results.-The
higher rate of perinatal death in the United States compared with Norw
ay is due to an excess of preterm deliveries in the United States. Low
-weight, preterm births comprise 2.9% of US births compared with 2.1%
of Norwegian births. If the United States could eliminate this slight
excess of preterm delivery, perinatal mortality in the United States w
ould decrease to the level in Norway. Unexpectedly, the survival of ne
wborns at any given birth weight is virtually the same in the United S
tates and Norway when newborns' birth weights are considered relative
to their own nation's mean weight. Conclusions.-Low rates of perinatal
mortality in the Scandinavian countries have usually been attributed
to the heavier weights of their newborns. Higher mortality among US in
fants is in fact due entirety to a small excess of preterm deliveries.
The lighter weights of US newborns at term appear not to affect perin
atal survival. Furthermore, the apparent survival advantage of low-wei
ght US newborns (used by policymakers as evidence of superior US inten
sive neonatal care) may be at [east partly an artifact. When weight-sp
ecific mortality rates are adjusted to relative birth weight, low-weig
ht newborns have the same survival in Norway as in the United States.
The prevention of excess mortality among US infants depends on the pre
vention of preterm births, not on changes in mean birth weight.