The use of quasigeostrophic Q-vector diagnosis for marine cyclogenesis
is examined for two cases from the Experiment on Rapidly Intensifying
Cyclones over the Atlantic. Surface observations plus aircraft observ
ations and satellite imagery are used to objectively analyze these cas
es, and Q vectors are calculated from these surface analyses. Although
application of omega equation diagnosis at the surface stretches the
theory, the relationship between vertical motion in cyclones and Q vec
tors suggests that a useful diagnosis can be made. The accuracy and us
efulness of these surface-based Q vectors for the two cases are examin
ed subjectively through comparisons tb satellite imagery and cyclone c
onceptual models as well as objectively through statistical comparison
with future pressure tendencies. Results of these comparisons suggest
that useful representations of the synoptic-scale vertical motion can
be determined from a surface Q-vector diagnosis. This Q-vector diagno
sis can be used to help assess the numerical model guidance routinely
available to operational forecasters by highlighting regions of signif
icant low-level forcing and providing insight into the future track of
a developing cyclone.