E. Orr et B. Dinur, SOCIAL SETTING EFFECTS ON GENDER DIFFERENCES IN SELF-ESTEEM - KIBBUTZAND URBAN ADOLESCENTS, Journal of youth and adolescence, 24(1), 1995, pp. 3-27
The study investigated the effect of two multidimensional systems-name
ly social setting and the self-upon adolescents' growth and developmen
t. Specifically, we hypothesized that gender differences in adult soci
al status ave greater in the kibbutz than in the Israeli urban setting
, and that this gap is associated with gender differences in global se
lf-esteem among kibbutz youth. The Rosenberg Self-esteem Scale, and sc
ales from Marsh's Self-Description Questionnaire III and from Harter's
Self-Perception Profile for Adolescents were administered to 569 kibb
utz and urban adolescents from Grades 9 to 11. Data on academic achiev
ement and parental status was also obtained. Kibbutz mothers were foun
d to have significantly lower social status than fathers, while kibbut
z girls had significantly lower self-esteem than kibbutz boys and urba
n adolescents of both sexes. The organization of the self-concept of k
ibbutz females differed from the other groups: self-esteem was predict
ed not only from self-concepts in the domains of scholastic achievemen
t and peer support but also from the domain of parental support, from
academic achievement, and from father's occupational status.