There is lingering disagreement over the relative oxidation kinetics o
f SiC and Si3N4 in the regime of passive oxidation. Various oxidation
enthalpies have been reported for these materials, in some cases with
suggestions of an increase at higher temperatures. The result is uncer
tainty over the respective diffusion mechanisms that limit oxidation r
ates in these materials. It is suspected that this confusion mag be du
e, in large part, to the effects of impurities from the oxidation envi
ronment. Accordingly, this study was aimed at clarifying some of the i
ssues by undertaking the simultaneous oxidation of CVD SiC and Si3N4 w
ithin a furnace tube of fused silica known to be very pure. We discuss
the results obtained in the interval 1200 to 1500 degrees C, and thei
r implications on the respective rate-limiting mechanisms.