C. Andersson et al., DIAGNOSIS OF ACUTE INTERMITTENT PORPHYRIA IN NORTHERN SWEDEN - AN EVALUATION OF MUTATION ANALYSIS AND BIOCHEMICAL METHODS, Journal of internal medicine, 237(3), 1995, pp. 301-308
Objective. To validate the use of a recently observed guanine to adeni
ne mutation in exon 10 in the porphobilinogen deaminase (PBGD) gene as
a diagnostic marker of acute intermittent porphyria (AIP). To evaluat
e the efficiency of the traditional biochemical diagnostic methods. De
sign. Matched and blinded case-control study (1:4). Setting. A primary
health care centre in Arjeplog, the National Porphyria Research Unit
and a department of clinical genetics in Stockholm. Subjects. A total
of 48/49 (98%) patients over the age of 15 years living in Arjeplog wi
th AIP, diagnosed according to standard clinical and biochemical crite
ria. For each AIP patient, four controls were matched for age, sex and
geographical area and 164/196 (86%) participated. In the validity stu
dy, 35 patients were selected as indisputable AIP gene carriers, accor
ding to strict biochemical criteria, and 92 matched controls were sele
cted with strict exclusion criteria. Main outcome measures. Validity,
specificity and sensitivity of DNA diagnosis for this AIP mutation. Sp
ecificity and sensitivity of traditional biochemical methods. Results.
Validity study: the mutation was found in all 35 individuals classifi
ed as carriers of AIP. None of the 92 controls had the mutation. Evalu
ation study: all 48 AIP gene carriers, diagnosed by traditional method
s, had the mutation, as had one of the control persons. In an inconclu
sive group of five persons with heredity for AIP, two had a positive D
NA test. Conclusions. The PBGD mutation analysis was found to have ful
l specificity and sensitivity and can be used as the sole diagnostic m
ethod in the family complex studied, representing the major AIP mutati
on in Sweden. The traditional diagnostic methods, used in optimal comb
inations, work in most cases, but they do not show high precision. How
ever, they must be used when the specific mutation in the PBGD gene is
not known.