IMMUNOHISTOCHEMICAL DETECTION OF HER2 NEU IN PATIENTS WITH AXILLARY LYMPH-NODE NEGATIVE BREAST-CARCINOMA - A STUDY OF EPIDEMIOLOGIC RISK FACTORS, HISTOLOGIC FEATURES, AND PROGNOSIS/
Pp. Rosen et al., IMMUNOHISTOCHEMICAL DETECTION OF HER2 NEU IN PATIENTS WITH AXILLARY LYMPH-NODE NEGATIVE BREAST-CARCINOMA - A STUDY OF EPIDEMIOLOGIC RISK FACTORS, HISTOLOGIC FEATURES, AND PROGNOSIS/, Cancer, 75(6), 1995, pp. 1320-1326
Background. Numerous studies have examined the prognostic significance
of HER2/neu (HER) expression in patients with axillary lymph node neg
ative breast carcinoma. Although some investigations suggest that the
presence of the altered expression of HER is prognostically unfavorabl
e, the subject remains controversial. This study explores the interact
ion of HER with three aspects of axillary lymph node negative breast c
arcinoma: epidemiologic risk factors, tumor histopathology, and progno
sis. Methods. Immunohistochemical staining for HER was performed on 10
% formalin fixed paraffin embedded primary carcinomas from 440 patient
s with negative axillary lymph nodes with a median follow-up of 119 mo
nths. Results. The immunohistochemical expression, or lack thereof, of
HER did not prove to be prognostically significant in this group of p
atients with axillary lymph node negative breast carcinoma. There was
also no consistent association with epidemiologic risk factors. The mo
st striking results concerned the relationship of HER to histopatholog
ic features of the carcinomas. Medullary carcinoma differed from other
tumor types because it was HER(+) substantially less often (10%) than
were other ductal (49%) or lobular (43%) carcinomas. Conclusion. The
results obtained in this study suggest that the immunohistochemical de
monstration of HER is not a reliable prognostic indicator for patients
with axillary lymph node negative breast carcinoma. This marker was n
ot associated with major epidemiologic risk factors; however, there wa
s a significant correlation between HER and the phenotypic features of
breast carcinoma because medullary carcinoma is rarely HER(+). Althou
gh the associations may not be a strong enough basis for refining the
classification of breast carcinoma, they could be useful for diagnosin
g individual patients. The changes in HER that are detectable by the i
mmunohistochemical methods used in this study probably do not occur in
the earliest stages of mammary carcinogenesis.