Ah. Swirnoff et J. Milbrandt, DNA-BINDING SPECIFICITY OF NGFI-A AND RELATED ZINC-FINGER TRANSCRIPTION FACTORS, Molecular and cellular biology, 15(4), 1995, pp. 2275-2287
NGFI-A is the prototypic member of a family of immediate-early gene-en
coded transcription factors which includes NGFI-C, Egr3, and Krox20. T
hese proteins possess highly homologous DNA-binding domains, composed
of three Cys(2)-His(2) zinc fingers, and all bind to and activate tran
scription from the sequence GCGGGGGCG. We used a PCR-mediated random s
ite selection protocol to determine whether other sites could be bound
by these proteins and the extent to which their binding site preferen
ces are similar or different. The high-affinity consensus sites genera
ted from the selection data are similar, and the combined consensus se
quence is T-G-C-G-T/g-G/A-G-G-C/a/t-G-G/T (lowercase letters indicate
bases selected less frequently). Using gel shift assays, we found that
sequences that diverge from the consensus were bound by NGFI-A, confi
rming that there is greater variability in binding sites than has gene
rally been acknowledged. We also provide evidence that protein-DNA int
eractions not noted, or whose importance was not apparent from the X-r
ay cocrystal structure of the NGFI-A zinc fingers complexed with DNA,
contribute significantly to the binding energy of these proteins and c
onfirm that an optimal site is at least 10 instead of 9 nucleotides in
length. In contrast to the similarities in binding specificity among
these proteins, we found that while NGFI-A, Egr3, and Krox20 have comp
arable DNA binding affinities and kinetics of dissociation, the affini
ty of NGFI-C is more than threefold lower. This could result in differ
ential regulation of target genes in cells where NGFI-C and the other
proteins are coexpressed. Furthermore, we show that this affinity diff
erence is a property not of the zinc fingers themselves but rather of
the protein context of the DNA-binding domain.