Purpose: Despite numerous studies, there has been no definitive HLA as
sociation with Peyronie's disease. Results of available studies have b
een reviewed and compared to determine if the cumulative evidence supp
orts any immunogenetic, HLA association with Peyronie's disease. Mater
ials and Methods: Data from reports of HLA associations with Peyronie'
s disease were reanalyzed by categories of reported HLA class I or cla
ss II antigens in comparison with recently available large population
analysis of the frequencies of these antigens in the normal population
. Data were also considered by whether they were derived from populati
on or family analyses. Results: The results of 4 series of patients te
sting an association of Peyronie's disease with the HLA class I antige
ns, in particular the B7 related antigens, were contradictory. A B7 as
sociation was not confirmed in 2 larger series and, in fact, the B7 re
lated antigens were observed in frequencies expected in a normal popul
ation, suggesting that the associations observed in the smaller series
were due to chance. An association with the HLA class II antigen, DQ2
, was found in 1 of the larger series. Reported family studies suggest
a genetic basis for Peyronie's disease but do not indicate a gene clo
sely linked to the HLA complex. Conclusions: Considering all available
data, Peyronie's disease appears to be multifactorial in pathogenesis
. Because Peyronie's disease is Likely heterogeneous and because avail
able studies have analyzed serologically defined HLA antigens, future
studies to define HLA alleles molecularly and to characterize patient
subgroups may clarify an immunogenetic basis.