Ir. Fraser et al., A PROSPECTIVE-STUDY OF CORTICAL SCARRING IN ACUTE FEBRILE PYELONEPHRITIS IN ADULTS - CLINICAL AND BACTERIOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS, Clinical nephrology, 43(3), 1995, pp. 159-164
Previous reports have demonstrated lesions on computerized axial tomog
raphy (CT), and nuclear scintigraphy (DMSA) in acute pyelonephritis (P
N). We undertook a prospective study of all patients presenting to our
hospital with PN over 40 months. Patients who fulfilled diagnostic cr
iteria, were treated with intravenous antibiotics. Excluding two who w
ere pregnant, all patients had imaging by intravenous urography (IVU),
CT and DMSA during their admission. Urine samples were collected prio
r to treatment. Patients without lVU evidence of cortical scarring but
with parenchymal defects on CT and/or DMSA underwent a repeat DMSA th
ree or more months after the acute episode. Of the 164 patients, 142 w
ere female. E. coli was found in 116 patients. Forty-six patients had
an abnormality on IVU. Of the 106 patients without IVU evidence of cor
tical scarring, 59 had a defect on CT and/or DMSA. Late DMSA scans in
35 of these 59 patients showed a persistent abnormality in 77%. E. col
i characteristics such as P-fimbriae and Type 1 fimbriae were not pred
ictive of acute imaging abnormalities. Inhibition of E. coli growth by
the addition of EDTA was highly predictive of acute CT and DMSA abnor
malities with a sensitivity of 83.3% and a specificity of 82.8%. Acute
pyelonephritis is often associated with acute CT and/or DMSA abnormal
ities which may evolve into renal cortical scars. Acute scan abnormali
ties can be predicted by the presence of E. coli which were susceptibl
e to EDTA in culture. Late scarring could not be predicted by clincial
features, response to treatment or antibiotic used.