Jp. Rushton et Rt. Osborne, GENETIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONTRIBUTIONS TO CRANIAL CAPACITY IN BLACK-AND-WHITE ADOLESCENTS, Intelligence, 20(1), 1995, pp. 1-13
Data from 236 pairs of twins (472 individuals) aged 13 to 17 years wer
e used to examine genetic and environmental factors influencing crania
l size, an indirect estimate of brain volume. Measures were taken of z
ygosity, head length, head breadth, age, sex, race, height, and weight
for 187 males and 285 females, 222 Whites and 250 Blacks, Cranial siz
e was estimated from head length and head breadth using standard equat
ions. Group differences were found. Cranial capacity increased over ag
e 13 to 17 from 1,233 cm(3) to 1,279 cm(3). After adjusting for the ef
fects of age and body size, boys averaged 1,290 cm(3) and girls 1,229
cm(3), Whites averaged 1,269 cm(3) and Blacks 1,251 cm(3). Intraclass
correlations were calculated and models fitted of proportionate geneti
c and environmental contributions to variance. Depending on particular
corrections for body size, heritabilities for the sample as a whole r
anged from 38% to 51% with 6% to 20% due to common environment and fro
m 42% to 52% due to unique (nonshared) environmental factors, includin
g error variance. The proportionate contributions did not vary systema
tically by sex and the seemingly higher range of heritabilities estima
ted for Whites than for Blacks (47% to 56% against 12% to 31%) and the
lower range of common environment effects for Whites than for Blacks
(28% to 32% against 42% to 46%) did not differ significantly In conclu
sion, it is indicated that genetic factors are required to account for
the phenotypic variance in cranial capacity and that further research
is required on whether environmental factors exert more influence in
Black populations than in White populations.