Mk. Schubauerberigan et al., INFLUENCE OF PH ON THE TOXICITY OF AMMONIA TO CHIRONOMUS-TENTANS AND LUMBRICULUS-VARIEGATUS, Environmental toxicology and chemistry, 14(4), 1995, pp. 713-717
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency water-quality criteria establ
ish permissible levels of ammonia in the nation's fresh waters. These
criteria are based on accumulated research suggesting that, for most a
quatic species (primarily fishes), the toxicity of un-ionized ammonia
predominates over that of the ammonium ion. The development of a sedim
ent-quality criterion for ammonia requires evaluation of the relative
toxicity of the two ammonia forms to benthic and epibenthic macroinver
tebrates to determine whether the water-quality toxicity model can be
applied to sediments. Flow-through ammonia toxicity tests were conduct
ed over 10 d with the oligochaete Lumbriculus variegatus and the larva
l midge Chironomus tentans at four pH values (6.3, 7.2, 7.8, and 8.6)
using a unique pH control system. Total ammonia was more toxic at elev
ated than at low pH to both species, suggesting that un-ionized ammoni
a (more prevalent at high pH) is important in determining the toxicity
of ammonia to these two species. Hardness or alkalinity differences i
n the range of 30 to 200 mg/kg (as CaCO3) did not appear to affect the
toxicity of ammonia to the two species in separate 4-d tests. Based o
n results of the 10-d tests, the joint toxicity/pH model that establis
hes the water-quality criterion value for ammonia appears to be suffic
iently protective of L. variegatus and C. tentans, by factors of at le
ast 3 and 10, respectively. However, this study did not address potent
ial differences in exposure of benthic organisms to ammonia in sedimen
ts vs. that in the water column; nor were the chronic effects of ammon
ia on these species measured in this study.