Gd. Montoya et al., AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECT OF DECREASING THE SIZE RESOLUTION IN 2 TECHNIQUES TO SOLVE THE STOCHASTIC COLLECTION EQUATION FOR GROWING CLOUD DROPS, Atmospheric research, 35(2-4), 1995, pp. 173-188
A comparison is made between the methods for solving the stochastic co
llection equation of Berry and Reinhardt, using 72 categories, and the
method of moments as improved by Tzivion et al., using only 36 classe
s. The computations, carried out for different kernels and several ini
tial mean drop radii, showed that the numerical acceleration inherent
to the Bleck's method is also present in the approach of Tzivion et al
., but in a weaker form. This acceleration depends on the type of kern
el and, for cloud conditions allowing coalescence development, it rema
ins between acceptable limits and decreases with time. When the method
of moments is run for 72 categories, the numerical acceleration pract
ically disappears. Although, in terms of mass storage, the requirement
s of both methods are the same, in terms of computational speed, this
approach has advantages over Berry and Reinhardt's method for use in c
loud models with detailed description of microphysical processes.