Es. Reed et al., METHOD FOR STUDYING THE INVARIANT KNOWLEDGE STRUCTURE OF ACTION - CONCEPTUAL ORGANIZATION OF AN EVERYDAY ACTION, The American journal of psychology, 108(1), 1995, pp. 37-65
A method is described for analyzing the cognitive structure inherent i
n an everyday action. This structure includes not only units of the ac
tion and their serial order, but also the aggregation of these units i
nto various higher level units that function as components of the acti
on. It is hypothesized that a special kind of unit, the crux, function
s at every level of the action as an organizing center for units at th
at level. The method developed here begins with actual performances of
a task, deriving the units of action within that task from consistenc
ies across different subjects' performance in order to identify units
that are invariant across everyday variations in styles of performance
. A description of the task in terms of these units was given to naive
adults who were required to make either local judgments of similarity
among these units or a global judgment concerning how the units aggre
gate to organize the task. These judgments were analyzed in several wa
ys to try to find invariant patterns of aggregation of the units. The
evidence suggests that, at least for the task under study here (toothb
rushing), such invariant hierarchical patterns are found and that they
are based on cruxes.