Bj. Mcgrory et al., PARTICIPATION IN SPORTS AFTER HIP AND KNEE ARTHROPLASTY - REVIEW OF LITERATURE AND SURVEY OF SURGEON PREFERENCES, Mayo Clinic proceedings, 70(4), 1995, pp. 342-348
Objective: To summarize previously published findings and to present t
he opinion of a group of reconstructive orthopedic surgeons from a sin
gle institution on participation in sports after hip or knee arthropla
sty. Design: We reviewed the literature pertaining to participation in
sports after hip or knee arthroplasty and surveyed a group of orthope
dic surgeons about their recommendations for resumption of various spo
rts activities by patients who had undergone total hip or knee arthrop
lasty. Material and Methods: A computerized literature search was perf
ormed, and salient issues about participation in sports after joint re
placement procedures were synthesized. At the Mayo Clinic, 28 orthoped
ic surgeons (13 consultants and 15 fellows or residents) completed a s
ingle-page questionnaire that requested a recommendation (''yes,'' ''n
o,'' or ''depends'') about patients resuming participation in 28 commo
n sports after recovery from total hip or knee arthroplasty. Staff sur
geon responses were compared with responses from fellows and residents
by using the Mann-Whitney U test. Sports in which 75% of surgeons wou
ld not allow participation were identified as ''not recommended,'' whe
reas sports in which 75% of surgeons would allow participation were la
beled as ''recommended.'' Results: Fellows and residents were less lik
ely than staff surgeons to allow return to cross-country skiing after
total knee arthroplasty. Otherwise, responses from consultant surgeons
and from fellows and residents did not differ significantly. Recommen
ded sports included sailing, swimming laps, scuba diving, cycling, gol
fing, and bowling after hip and knee replacement procedures and also c
ross-country skiing after knee arthroplasty. Sports not recommended af
ter hip or knee arthroplasty were running, waterskiing, football, base
ball, basketball, hockey, handball, karate, soccer, and racquetball. C
onclusion: After hip or knee arthroplasty, participation in no-impact
or low-impact sports can be encouraged, but participation in high-impa
ct sports should be prohibited.