New Zealand restructured its health system in 1992 with the aim of ach
ieving greater levels of assessment and accountability in the publicly
funded health sector. A committee was established specifically to adv
ise the minister of health on the kinds, and relative priorities, of h
ealth services that should be publicly funded. One of its projects has
been to develop standardised sets of criteria to assess the extent of
benefit expected from elective surgical procedures. These have been d
eveloped with the help of professional advisory groups using a modifie
d Delphi technique to reach consensus. So far the committee has develo
ped criteria for cataract surgery, coronary artery bypass grafting, hi
p and knee replacement, cholecystectomy, and tympanostomy tubes for od
ds media with effusion. These criteria incorporate both clinical and s
ocial factors. Use of priority criteria to ensure consistency and tran
sparency regarding patients' priority for surgery is required for acce
ss to a dedicated NZ$ 130m (f57m; US$90m) pool of money, created to he
lp eliminate surgical waiting lists and move to booking systems. The c
riteria will also be used in surgical outcome studies, currently in th
e planning phase.