B. Cote et al., POSSIBLE INTERFERENCE OF FERTILIZATION IN THE NATURAL RECOVERY OF A DECLINING SUGAR MAPLE STAND IN SOUTHERN QUEBEC, Plant and soil, 169, 1995, pp. 471-480
A five year study was conducted in a 100-120 year old even-aged sugar
maple stand in southern Quebec (46 degrees 07'N 73 degrees 56'W; 305 m
altitude) to explore the effect of different fertilization formulatio
ns aimed at 1) correcting the most common nutrient deficiencies observ
ed in declining maple stands (K and Mg), 2) decreasing soil acidity, a
nd 3) simulating enrichment with atmospheric N. Seven fertilizer mixtu
res were applied in the spring of 1987: 400 kg ha(-1) of K2SO4, CaCO3,
CaMg(CO3)(2), (NH4)(2)SO4, complete fertilizer (''Maplegro'') and 800
kg ha(-1) of an equal mixture of K2SO4 + CaCO3 or K2SO4 + CaMg(CO3)(2
). The site was divided into twenty-four 25 x 25 m plots and treatment
s including control were replicated three times. Leaves and soils (org
anic and mineral) were sampled in 1987, 1988 and 1991. Trees were core
d at 1.2 m to measure their response in diameter growth. The applicati
on of K2SO4 + CaMg(CO3)(2) was the only treatment that significantly i
ncreased (+13%) the average growth rate over the five year period afte
r fertilization. The application of(NH4)(2)SO4, ''Maplegro'' CaMg(CO3)
(2) and K2SO4 reduced growth relative to the control for the five year
period by 29, 24, 20 and 12 %, respectively. Positive and negative ef
fects on growth can be explained mainly in terms of changes in leaf K.
Both the application of Maplegro and (NH4)(2)SO4 increased soil P ava
ilability. Overall, the rate of growth showed a cubic pattern of chang
e over the 5 year period with peaks in 1988 and 1991. Trees in control
plots went from a limiting foliar status of Ca and Mg, and surplus N
in 1987 to a surplus of Ca and Mg, and lower N concentration in 1991.
Our results suggest that nutrient deficiencies observed at our site we
re associated with a disturbance of the biogeochemical cycle of nutrie
nts rather than soil nutrient depletion.