F. Cordier, DO CATEGORIZATION PROCESSES ORIGINATE FROM ELEMENT SUBSTITUTIONS WITHIN A SCRIPT, Cahiers de psychologie cognitive, 15(6), 1996, pp. 583-598
Is organizing into categories strictly related to grouping elements th
at can be substituted for each other within a script? This hypothesis
by Nelson (1986) was tested using an original drawing choice task whic
h enabled us to distinguish between thematic choices, a slot-filler or
ganization within a script, and taxonomic choices. Three groups of chi
ldren were tested, aged on the average 4 and a half, 5 and a half, and
6 and a half. The ''filiation'' hypothesis was tested by analyzing th
e distribution of choices in each age group. Nelson's hypothesis was n
ot verified: elements that could be substituted within a script were n
ot chosen frequently by the younger children. The process of substitut
ing elements within a script was observed for man-made objects only. T
his seems to be an indication that Nelson's hypotheses pertain to the
formation of categories of man-made objects, which children are more l
ikely to know through their actions.