Morphologically, bone marrow is made up of a relatively mature but het
erogenous population, fueled by a tiny pool of microscopically unrecog
nizable stem and progenitor cells. This complex tissue has the respons
ibility of maintaining our hematopoietic and, to a large extent, immun
ologic integrity, both of which are indispensable for health and, inde
ed, survival. Perhaps not surprisingly, bone marrow is the target of g
enetic, autoimmune, and environmental insults. Although robust, it has
only a limited number of responses, one of which is reduction in cell
ular output, sometimes with superimposed qualitative abnormalities, an
d this is defined as bone marrow failure. Bone marrow failure is a div
erse entity but can be logically explained and classified on a pathoph
ysiologic basis. Thus the major recognizable categories of bone marrow
failure are congenital and acquired defects. Each of these is subdivi
ded according to the number of cell lines involved, over and above whi
ch the severity of the damage will determine reversibility. In each ca
se, the natural history dictates management, and this ranges from shor
t-term growth factor support to biologic immune response modulation an
d finally to bone marrow transplantation. In the past, many clinicopat
hologic variants of bone marrow failure were described, although their
etiology was obscure and effective therapy was unavailable. This chan
ged dramatically, however, when experimental hematologists, using radi
obiology models, uncovered the dynamic nature of blood formation. Card
inal observations included the way in which spontaneous recovery follo
wed irradiation, the central role played by pluripotential stem cells,
and the integral participation of stroma in modulating this entire pr
ocess. Understanding was refined once bone marrow cultures became avai
lable while, in paralle, the use of in-bred mouse strains launched the
era of allogeneic transplantation. These approaches were combined, an
d the broad principles that govern basal or constitutive production em
erged. Stem cells, with their characteristic commitment to self-renewa
l, exist at the apex of a hierarchy and generate a tier of proliferati
ng progenitors that, in turn, give rise to a large postmitotic compart
ment of precursors that mature into distinctive myeloid and lymphoid l
ineages. The reserve potential is enormous, and output can be induced
to meet even greatly increased demands. These events reflect the inter
action of growth factors with a balancing set of negative regulators.
The link between such diverse functions resides, to a large extent, in
accessory cells and matrix geographically organized in what is now de
scribed as the hematopoietic inductive microenvironment. Many details
of these meticulously orchestrated processes are obscure. For example,
how are adhesion proteins, expressed on vascular endothelium, subtly
altered to facilitate release of mature cells into the circulation? En
igmatic also is the way in which membrane antigens change during recov
ery from chemotherapy or in response to growth factors, so that early
progenitors flood the circulation and can be collected for subsequent
autografting. In spite of our new-found knowledge, patient management
is often empiric. To illustrate this point, consider the inherited Jos
ephs - Diamond - Blackfan anemia or global aplasia described by Fancon
i, in which undoubted benefit - indeed cure - is possible with the non
selective transplantation of marrow. Our understanding of this process
is rather crude and is a far cry from the exquisite specificity with
which a solitary molecular defect, once defined, can be repaired using
gene therapy. Patients with acquired lesions are little better off. S
ome, such as those with idiopathic pure red cell aplasia, enjoy sponta
neous remission, whereas others require varying degrees of pharmacolog
ic immunosuppression. Perhaps more frustrating are the many cases of u
nexplained loss of hematopoietic tissue. It has been suggested that su
ch individuals have a genetically fragile marrow that collapses when s
ubjected to a relatively minor environmental insult and that possibly
the collapse is acting through an immunologic mechanism. For want of a
precise molecular diagnosis, the same relatively unsophisticated ther
apeutic approaches are used in these patients, albeit with substantial
success. In this context, allogeneic transplantation is limited by re
jection, whereas stable engraftment may be tarnished by the not insign
ificant incidences of morbidity and mortality that result from graft-v
ersus-host disease. Unfortunately, even this option is not always avai
lable, and alternatives such as antilymphocyte globulin, which do brin
g about quantitative responses, may be followed by the later developme
nt of myelodysplasia or acute leukemia. These obvious shortcomings pro
mpted investigators to study closely the convoluted trail that leads b
ack to faulty DNA to allow more exact intervention. Against this backg
round, there arises the question of how to structure a pragmatic and r
elatively uniform approach to the care of patients with bone marrow fa
ilure. Logically, treatment modalities should center on the currently
understood model of hematopoiesis, in which lesions can arise in early
stem cells, resulting in aplasia. This is in contrast to the damage o
f already committed progenitors in which, at least initially, single l
ineages are affected. Within each category, the defect may be inherite
d or acquired. Approached pathophysiologically, an algorithm for treat
ment evolves naturally and advocates simple support for those in whom
spontaneous recovery is predicted, although this increasingly incorpor
ates the use of recombinant human growth factors or interleukins, whic
h are often given together. For irreversible damage, bone marrow trans
plantation is currently the treatment of choice. If this option is lac
king, immuno-suppressive regimens are effective, with the caveat that
complications must be anticipated. The future is somewhat brighter, wi
th the promise that more precise molecular diagnosis is, in many cases
, well within our grasp. Armed with such vital information, gene thera
py becomes a realistic possibility; precedent already exists in which
adenosine deaminase deficiency, an otherwise lethal immunologic disord
er, can be precisely corrected.