Aj. Treloar et Ajd. Macdonald, RECOGNITION OF COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT BY DAY AND NIGHT NURSING STAFF AMONG ACUTE GERIATRIC-PATIENTS, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 88(4), 1995, pp. 196-198
The recognition of cognitive impairment by day and night nursing staff
was studied in an acute geriatric unit. Seventy-six patients were ran
domly selected from a prospective sample of admissions. DSM-III-R diag
noses were established on all patients. Day and night staff were inter
viewed about each patient's clinical condition and asked to state whet
her or not they thought they were cognitively impaired or confused. Da
y staff were reasonably good at differentiating cognitively unimpaired
from those with dementia and or delirium [kappa=0.62, 95% confidence
interval (Cl)=0.46-0.78]. All patients thought by day staff to be cogn
itively impaired were found to be so, although day staff did fail to i
dentify some patients with cognitive impairment. Night staff performed
less well (kappa=0.37, 95% Cl 0.18-0.57) and identified cognitively n
ormal patients as being cognitively impaired, as well as failing to id
entify patients who were cognitively impaired. Night nursing interview
s were not thought to have contributed to the management of any patien
t. The usefulness of night-time nursing interviews for research and ge
neral inpatient management purposes is questioned and the importance o
f daytime nursing interviews emphasized.