Ur. Desai et Am. Klibanov, ASSESSING THE STRUCTURAL INTEGRITY OF A LYOPHILIZED PROTEIN IN ORGANIC-SOLVENTS, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 117(14), 1995, pp. 3940-3945
The structure of a model. protein, bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor
(BPTI), in organic solvents has been examined using hydrogen isotope
exchange/high-resolution NMR methodology. When lyophilized deuterated
BPTI is suspended in acetonitrile, tetrahydrofuran, ethyl acetate, or
butanol, each containing 1% (H2O)-H-1, several protein amide protons t
hat are buried and strongly hydrogen bonded in aqueous solution are fo
und to exchange with the solvent significantly within 24 h. In contras
t, in water most of these protons do not exchange appreciably even aft
er a week under otherwise similar conditions. The isotope exchange rat
es of the corresponding amide protons of BPTI are similar in these non
aqueous solvents, as well as in acetonitrile containing methanol or bu
tanol (instead of water) as a H donor. When solid BPTI is prepared by
different methods, such as rotary evaporation, acetone precipitation,
or lyophilization from a dimethyl sulfoxide solution, and subsequently
suspended in acetonitrile containing 1% water, the exchange intensiti
es of the amide protons vary greatly among the preparations. These dat
a combined suggest that the structure of BPTI in the four aforemention
ed organic solvents is partially unfolded, but not more so than in lyo
philized powder, i.e., that these solvents cause little additional pro
tein denaturation beyond that brought about by lyophilization. Using t
he same methodology, the BPTI structure also has been studied in sever
al protein-dissolving solvents containing 1% water. In dimethyl sulfox
ide, dimethylformamide, or methanol, the same amide protons exchange a
lmost completely within 24 h, while in glycerol (known to stabilize pr
oteins and to function as a water mimic) they do not. These results de
monstrate that some protein-dissolving organic solvents strongly denat
ure BPTI and that intermolecular contacts in the suspended protein are
important in maintaining the protein conformation in organic solvents
. These findings, if general, explain the considerable but much reduce
d (compared to water) enzymatic activity in nonaqueous media.