Tj. Sinclair, BETWEEN STATE AND MARKET - HEGEMONY AND INSTITUTIONS OF COLLECTIVE ACTION UNDER CONDITIONS OF INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL MOBILITY, Policy sciences, 27(4), 1994, pp. 447-466
Citations number
60
Categorie Soggetti
Social, Sciences, Interdisciplinary","Planning & Development
This article rejects the atomistic conception of international capital
mobility as individual, uncoordinated decision-making. It argues that
non-state institutions exist in the global political economy which co
ndition the thoughts and actions that comprise the investment process.
Because these structure investment, such institutions can be understo
od as private makers of global public policy. Credit rating agencies a
re used as an example of these mechanisms. The article examines transf
ormations in the organization of capital markets which underpin the gr
eater influence of these agencies. Functional accounts of rating insti
tutions are evaluated, and their scope for transcending a strict agenc
y role with regard to investors is assessed, based on their possession
of specialized forms of knowledge from which they derive control. Som
e description of the agencies, their international growth and the rati
ngs process is provided. Three arguments about the pressures on the ec
onomic and financial structures identified by Zysman (1983) generated
by rating agencies are considered. Rating institutions create pressure
s for fundamental analyss of investment, for a particular View of appr
opriate management forms and policy lines along new constitutionalist
lines, and contribute to a more abstract investment process which is l
ikely to have the effect of transforming social relationships within t
he dominant alliances of social forces, The article concludes with som
e consideration of the implications of these hybrid forms of authority
and policy for world order.