V. Wolfe et al., ACOUSTIC PREDICTION OF SEVERITY IN COMMONLY OCCURRING VOICE PROBLEMS, Journal of speech and hearing research, 38(2), 1995, pp. 273-279
The relative effectiveness of three acoustic measures (jitter, shimmer
, and harmonic/noise ratio) in predicting the dysphonic severity of a
diverse clinical population singly and together was investigated. Phon
atory samples were recorded from 20 normal subjects and 60 patients re
presenting 3 laryngeal groups (nodules, paralysis, and functional). Th
e phonatory samples were evaluated by 22 listeners using a 7-point equ
al-appearing interval scale. Shimmer produced a bivariate correlation
of 0.54 with dysphonic severity; harmonic/noise ratio correlated - 0.3
2 with dysphonic severity; and jitter produced no significant correlat
ion with severity. The combination of acoustic variables through multi
ple regression analysis produced a correlation of 0.56, with only shim
mer and average F(o) contributing to the correlation. For this particu
lar clinical population, therefore, findings indicated that (a) none o
f the variables was strongly correlated with dysphonia ratings, and (b
) a combination of acoustic predictors was no more successful than a s
ingle predictor of dysphonic severity, namely, shimmer.