Mr. Jones et al., TESTS OF ATTENTIONAL FLEXIBILITY IN LISTENING TO POLYRHYTHMIC PATTERNS, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance, 21(2), 1995, pp. 293-307
Four experiments examined attentional flexibility in listening to poly
rhythmic patterns. Musically trained and untrained listeners detected
changes in timing of 1 tone (the lower tone) in a 3:2 polyrhythm in wh
ich high and low tones varied in frequency separation. Experiment 1 en
couraged integrative attending; all listeners performed significantly
poorer in conditions with wide as opposed to narrow frequency separati
ons. Experiment 2, which encouraged selective attending to low tones,
reversed these results: Performance was poorer in the narrow frequency
conditions. In neither experiment did skill interact with frequency s
eparation. Experiments 3 and 4 extended these findings to moderate fre
quency separations. Over all experiments, musically trained listeners
exhibited an enhanced ability to detect timing variations, but not fle
xibility of perceptual organization as it applies to detection of timi
ng changes. Instead, pattern structure (e.g., frequency and time relat
ion) decisively influenced perception for both levels of skill.