Dd. Bogard et al., AR-39-AR-40 AGE AND PETROLOGY OF CHICO - LARGE-SCALE IMPACT MELTING ON THE L-CHONDRITE PARENT BODY, Geochimica et cosmochimica acta, 59(7), 1995, pp. 1383-1399
Our studies of the 105 kg Chico L chondrite show that it contains simi
lar to 60% impact melt and the largest volume of impact melt recognize
d in stony meteorites. We suggest that it is part of a much larger dik
e complex that formed when chondritic impact melt was intruded into ho
st chondrite during a large, if not catastrophic, impact on the L chon
drite parent body at about 0.5 Ga. Petrologic and Ar-39-Ar-40 dating s
tudies were made on several lithologies, including the massive melt zo
ne, host chondrite, and melt-chondrite boundaries, for the purpose of
studying the melting and thermal histories associated with impacts on
small bodies and their effects on the K-Ar chronometer. The chondritic
host is shocked to stage S6 and contains pockets and veins of melt. T
here are no unmelted clasts in the interior of the melt; coalesced met
al-troilite nodules reach up to 2 cm in size. Melt near the contact wi
th the host chondrite contains numerous clasts and quenched more rapid
ly. Metal-troilite textures suggest cooling rates of similar to 0.1 de
grees C/s in the interior of the melt dike during crystallization. Sec
ondary kamacite rims indicate cooling at 0.01-1 degrees C/y over the r
ange of 700-500 degrees C, consistent with an impact-heated volume of
up to a kilometer in thickness. Compositions of olivines and pyroxenes
are generally similar in melt and chondritic host, reflecting rapid c
rystallization, not metamorphic equilibration. The interior melt shows
an overall depletion in K, whereas the melt near the boundary is enri
ched in K. The Ar-39-Ar-40 release spectra during stepwise heating of
both melt and chondrite samples can be divided into two parts, based o
n Ar diffusion properties and K/Ca ratios. The low-temperature, high K
/Ca phase of both melt and host chondrite show ages of 0.54-0.78 Ga. A
ges of the high-temperature, low K/Ca phase of the melt are comparable
or higher, 0.61-1.35 Ga, whereas those of the host chondrite are even
higher, 0.87-1.86 Ga, due to lesser degrees of degassing. Isochron pl
ots for several melt samples suggest an age of similar to 0.53 Ga and
the presence of variable amounts of excess Ar-40 not completely degass
ed by the impact. Even this age, however, is significantly higher than
the previously reported Rb-Sr isochron age of 0.467 +/- .015 Ga. The
apparent retention of radiogenic Ar-40 in the Chico impact melt, in sp
ite of its relatively large size, absence of clasts, and moderately sl
ow cooling rate below 700 degrees C, raises questions as to the reliab
ility of using melts for Ar-39-Ar-40 dating of meteoritic impact event
s.