Ai. Troster et al., THE INFLUENCE OF DEPRESSION ON COGNITION IN PARKINSONS-DISEASE - A PATTERN OF IMPAIRMENT DISTINGUISHABLE FROM ALZHEIMERS-DISEASE, Neurology, 45(4), 1995, pp. 672-676
Conflicting reports about the effects of depression on cognition in Pa
rkinson's disease (PD) are difficult to interpret because they are bas
ed on small sample sizes and confound depression with other variables.
We found that a sample of 45 PD patients with current depression was
cognitively more impaired than a sample of 45 PD patients without curr
ent depression matched for age, education, gender, age at disease onse
t, disease duration, and disease severity. The domains of cognition im
paired in the two PD groups (compared with 45 age-, education-, and ge
nder-matched controls) overlapped considerably, but (only the depresse
d PD group had impaired memory relative to the control group. Our comp
arison of 22 depressed PD patients and 22 Alzheimer's disease (AD) pat
ients matched for overall severity of cognitive impairment, age, educa
tion, and gender indicated that the depressed PD group performed signi
ficantly worse on visuoconstructive tasks and marginally worse on conc
eptualization tasks. In contrast, the AD group performed significantly
worse than the depressed PD group on memory tasks. Together, our resu
lts suggest that depression has a negative impact on cognition (and, i
n particular, memory) in PD, and that the pattern of this cognitive im
pairment is distinguishable from that associated with AD.