Cc. Naylor et al., RAMAN-SPECTROSCOPY EMPLOYED FOR THE DETERMINATION OF THE INTERMEDIATEPHASE IN POLYETHYLENE, Macromolecules, 28(8), 1995, pp. 2969-2978
The original work of Strobl and Hagedorn suggesting the presence of a
third intermediate phase in semicrystalline polyethylene was revisited
. The current study, involving the collection of Raman spectroscopic d
ata on a set of 16 polyethylene samples recorded on two different type
s of instruments in two different laboratories and employing two diffe
rent methods of curve fitting to both sets of experimental data, has r
evealed that the claims in the original paper cannot be asserted. The
most important reason leading to this conclusion is a problem incorrec
tly describing the complicated overlapping spectral structure in the 1
000-1200 and 1400-1500 cm(-1) spectral ranges. It is noted that the co
ntribution of the melt in the 1000-1150 cm(-1) range cannot be describ
ed by a single line centered around 1080 cm(-1). The present results i
ndicate that the quantification of a third, intermediate, phase in pol
yethylene is not possible when based on standard Raman spectra.