In a double blind study, eight horses were treated intravenously at se
ven-day intervals with detomidine at doses of 10, 20 and 10 mu g/kg, o
r with romifidine at doses of 40, 80 and 120 mu g/kg, or with a placeb
o solution. Their sedative and analgesic effects were evaluated by obj
ective measurements and by a clinician at 15-minute intervals for thre
e hours and the horses' instability in stocks, locomotor ataxia and he
art rate were recorded simultaneously. The administration of both drug
s at all doses resulted in sedation. The sedation achieved with romifi
dine was significantly shallower and shorter-lived than with detomidin
e at the recommended doses (P<0.05). The results obtained with the hig
hest dose of romifidine were in some cases significantly inferior and
shorter-lived than those obtained with the medium dose (P<0.05). Detom
idine at the 10 mu g/kg dose was similar in its effects to the two hig
hest doses of romifidine. At all doses detomidine had analgesic proper
ties against the effects of electrical pain stimulation at the withers
, the coronary bands on the front and hind legs, and in the perianal r
egion, which were dose-dependent in depth and duration, whereas romifi
dine was devoid of any analgesic effect. Instability and ataxia were m
ore pronounced with detomidine than with romifidine but the effects we
re only slight to moderate and not regarded as a hindrance to procedur
es for which sedation is needed. Bradycardia was evident with both dru
gs at all doses; its severity and duration was related to the sedative
properties of the drugs and was dose related. No other side effects w
ere observed.