According to the plant vigour hypothesis, galling insects should respo
nd positively and perform better on vigorous plants or plant parts, th
e opposite of the predictions of the plant stress hypothesis. I carrie
d out field experiments to analyse the effects of sustained abiotic st
ress on the interactions between the common reed (Phragmites australis
) and a gall-forming fly (Lipara lucens). The reed shoot diameter (a m
easure of plant vigour) is strongly affected by environmental conditio
ns, where dry and/or nutrient-poor habitats produce thinner (stressed)
shoots. L. lucens gall density is negatively correlated with shoot di
ameter. In a survival experiment with a wide range of shoot diameters,
larval mortality was also highly correlated with shoot quality. Gall
formation was higher on thinner, stressed shoots. An analysis of the g
all tissues revealed that galls induced by L. lucens contain a high am
ount of a nutrient-rich feeding tissue. The impact of L. lucens is hig
her on thinner shoots. The results of this study showed that L. lucens
performs better on stressed hosts, which contradicts the plant vigour
hypothesis for galling insects. The low nutrient availability in the
stressed shoots can be compensated by the production of galls with a n
utrient-rich feeding tissue.