Jm. Carroll et Ja. Russell, FACIAL EXPRESSIONS IN HOLLYWOOD PORTRAYAL OF EMOTION, Journal of personality and social psychology, 72(1), 1997, pp. 164-176
Much theory and research on emotion are based on the facial expression
s of amateurs asked to pose for still photographs. The theory of facia
l affect programs (FAPs; P. Ekman, 1972) was proposed to account for t
he resulting expressions, most of which are patterns consisting of dis
tinguishable parts. In the present study, 4 Hollywood films noted for
fine acting and realism were examined for the facial expressions that
accompany a basic emotion. In keeping with the theory of FAPs, profess
ional actors judged as happy were found smiling in 97% (Duchenne smili
ng in 74%) of cases. In contrast, actors judged as surprised, afraid,
angry disgusted, or sad rarely showed the predicted pattern (found in
0 to 31% of cases). Typically they used one or two parts from the full
pattern. If these films represent real life, these findings favor a t
heory that assumes separable parts (e.g., components theory) over the
older theory of FAPs.