Yg. Liu et al., CRAMBE MEAL - DIGESTIBILITY IN PIGS AND RATS IN COMPARISON WITH RAPESEED MEAL, Animal feed science and technology, 52(3-4), 1995, pp. 257-270
Seed meals from decorticated Crambe abyssinica (CM) and modern variety
rape (RSM) were compared for composition and digestibility. The struc
tural elements of the whole seeds (pericarp, seedcoat and endosperm) w
ere measured through hand-separation. In the digestion trial the decor
ticated and defatted meals were fed to four pigs (liveweight 35 kg) fi
tted with ileocaecal valve cannulas, Digestibility data were obtained
from a change-over experiment in which both meals were included at 300
g kg(-1) in the diet. Then the energy digestibility and nitrogen util
ization of the meals were determined in a balance trial with rats. The
whole crambe seeds contained 300 g pericarp kg(-1). After decorticati
on, the seeds possessed 89 g seedcoat kg(-1), significantly lower than
in rapeseed (160 g kg(-1)). Compared with RSM, CM contained a conside
rably higher level of protein (504 vs. 367 g kg(-1)) and a lower level
of fibre constituents (e.g. 65 vs, 139 g kg(-1) for crude fibre). App
arent total-tract digestibilities of gross energy for CM and RSM in pi
gs were 78.3 and 73.2% (P<0.05), of organic matter 78.7 and 73.2% (P<0
.05), and of protein 76.8 and 79.1%, respectively. However, the appare
nt ileal digestibility of protein in CM was lower than in RSM (63.0 vs
. 71.7%, P<0.01); that of lysine and cystine was also lower (61.1 and
62.5% for CM vs. 75.3 and 71.2% for RSM, P<0.01). The difference in pr
otein digestibility was presumably due to overheating of CM during the
detoxification treatment. Phosphorus total-tract digestibility was 43
.4% for CM and 22.5% for RSM (P<0.01). In the balance trial, rats rece
ived diets in which all nitrogen originated from either CM or RSM. The
results showed that CM had clearly higher apparent energy digestibili
ty than RSM (93.4 vs. 79.6%, P<0.01), Apparent protein digestibility w
as similar (78.4 vs. 78.8%), However, the biological value and net pro
tein utilization of CM were low, i.e. 46.8 and 41.7%, compared with 87
.1 and 77.6% for RSM (P<0.01). The differences were presumably due to
the high level of glucosinolates in CM. It is thus concluded that CM i
s highly digestible, and that there is large scope for enhancement in
protein utilization by optimizing the detoxification treatment.