DETERMINATION OF PHARMACOPHORIC GEOMETRY FOR COLLAGENASE INHIBITORS USING A NOVEL COMPUTATIONAL METHOD AND ITS VERIFICATION USING MOLECULAR-DYNAMICS, NMR, AND X-RAY CRYSTALLOGRAPHY
Ak. Ghose et al., DETERMINATION OF PHARMACOPHORIC GEOMETRY FOR COLLAGENASE INHIBITORS USING A NOVEL COMPUTATIONAL METHOD AND ITS VERIFICATION USING MOLECULAR-DYNAMICS, NMR, AND X-RAY CRYSTALLOGRAPHY, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 117(16), 1995, pp. 4671-4682
The pharmacophoric geometry for the inhibition of human fibroblast col
lagenase has been determined using a novel computational method. The i
nhibitors used in this study, which had from seven to 11 rotatable tor
sion angles, did not show any irreversible movement from the pharmacop
hore geometry during a 20 ps room temperature molecular dynamics simul
ation. A parallel NMR study confirmed two torsion angles and a key ato
m distance, and an X-ray crystallographic study of the protein-ligand
complex established the model unequivocally. The X-ray structure showe
d that nine out of 11 torsion angles were within the range predicted b
y the pharmacophoric model. For one of the two remaining torsion angle
s it suggested two possible values, one of which corresponded to the X
-ray structure, Molecular dynamics simulations starting from the compu
ted active conformation suggested that both of these two torsion angle
s could have alternate values which included the X-ray value. The comp
utational method described here is applicable to any general molecular
superimposition problem which, in rational drug design, helps: (i) to
visualize the similarities among the molecules of diverse structures;
(ii) to determine the active conformation for inhibiting a certain bi
ological system, which in turn can be used for developing SD-QSAR mode
ls; and (iii) to dock new ligands at the active site of an enzyme or a
biological receptor where the conformational correspondence with the
X-ray crystallographically solved ligand is not obvious. The method us
es multiple distance matrices to represent the conformational flexibil
ity and conformational diversity. The molecules may be fairly flexible
, with 10-12 rotatable torsion angles. No prior assumption of active c
onformation is necessary during the fitting process; only a hypothesis
of equivalent atoms is required to work with this method. The method
suggests conformations which are within a predefined molecular mechani
cs energy value and indicates the possibility of multiple conformation
al solutions if the molecules are not sufficiently diverse or constrai
ned.