Soil chemistry models often use gibbsite solubility and similar equili
brium models to predict Al concentrations in soil solution. A kinetic
alternative was developed with the goal of finding universal rate cons
tants instead of the site- and depth-specific solubility constants usu
ally associated with the equilibrium approach, The behavior of the two
approaches was studied within the framework of the steady-state soil
chemistry model PROFILE using data from Selling, Germany and Gardsjon,
Sweden, two sites with different mineralogy and land use history. The
kinetic alternative uses a mass balance to predict Al concentrations.
The sources of Al in soil water are deposition, weathering and minera
lization. The sinks are leaching and the formation of an aluminosilica
te precursor. The precursor slowly transforms into an ordinary clay mi
neral. Both formation and transformation of the precursor are treated
as irreversible processes. The kinetic model introduces a new relation
ship between pH and Al and produces a systematic pattern of different
apparent gibbsite equilibrium constants at different depths. Results s
how that the kinetic model systematically underestimates Al concentrat
ion in the upper horizons, which indicates that there may be additiona
l sources of Al in the upper horizons not accounted for in the model.
Predicted values of pH and Al concentrations are comparable with field
observations.