Je. Chamberlain et Ja. Nisker, RESIDENTS ATTITUDES TO TRAINING IN ETHICS IN CANADIAN OBSTETRICS AND GYNECOLOGY PROGRAMS, Obstetrics and gynecology, 85(5), 1995, pp. 783-786
Objective: To determine residents' attitudes toward their current trai
ning in ethics, including their preferred learning format, time commit
ment, and the influences of training and personal background on their
views and decision-making process. Method: All 203 residents from Engl
ish-speaking Canadian obstetrics and gynecology programs were mailed a
n 18-question, numerical-response questionnaire in prestamped return e
nvelopes. One hundred thirty-one residents (64.5%) responded (81 to th
e first mailing and 50 to the second). Results: The number of hours in
the residency program devoted to ethical issues correlated positively
with the residents' perception of the residency program in shaping th
eir ethical views (P = .015, r = 0.22). Of the respondents, 44.7% pref
erred case presentations as their learning format and 30.7% ranked sem
inars as their first choice. informal discussions and rounds were less
popular, and lectures were considered least appropriate by 69.3%. Whe
n asked what most influenced the residents' ethical decision-making pr
ocess, 34.2% indicated family views, 17.1% undergraduate teaching, 15.
4% religious background, 12.8% views of consulting staff, 11.1% reside
ncy training, and 9.4% peer attitudes. Sixty-eight percent of resident
s felt that their training in ethics during their residency program sh
ould be increased; this may reflect response bias. A position of consc
ience conflict during residency training was reported by 28.9% of resi
dents. Conclusion: Findings from this survey support the benefit of mo
re discussion of ethical issues during residency programs, particularl
y with the use of case presentations.