J. Quade et al., PALEODIETARY RECONSTRUCTION OF MIOCENE FAUNAS FROM PASALAR, TURKEY USING STABLE CARBON AND OXYGEN ISOTOPES OF FOSSIL TOOTH ENAMEL, Journal of Human Evolution, 28(4), 1995, pp. 373-384
Miocene-age (similar to 15 Ma) deposits at Pasalar in northwest Tur ke
v contain abundant and well-preserved dental remains from a variety of
herbivores. We used the carbon and oxygen isotopic compositions of in
organic carbonate in enamel from these teeth to reconstruct the paleod
iet and sources of body water, respectively, of Miocene mammals. The d
elta(13)C (PDB) values of carbonate in the enamel fall between -13.5 a
nd -9.0 parts per thousand, indicating a diet dominated by C-3 plants
for all mammals. Some species are distinctly different isotopically fr
om others, likely reflecting on variation in the delta(13)C values of
the plants being consumed. Giraffokeryx and Caprotragoides display the
most depleted delta(13)C values, probably indicating they were feedin
g upon C-3 plants experiencing low water stress and/or CO2 recycling,
such as in a forest. Hypsodontus and Conohyus, on the other hand, cons
istently display the most enriched delta(13)C values. They were theref
ore consuming isotopically enriched C-3 plants or a small quantity of
C-4 grasses. In either case, a more open habitat is indicated, The oth
er species we measured, including Griphopithecus, yielded intermediate
values. The delta(18)C (PDB) values of the carbonate in fossil enamel
also differ substantially between some taxa, and probably show that m
ammals such as Giraffokeryx, like East African giraffes today, were dr
awing their water from sources enriched in O-18, such as from the top
of a forest canopy.