Although reviled in the business press as short-term fads, rewards pro
grams are gaining popularity. Rewards can and do build customers' loya
lty. Unfortunately, they are widely misunderstood and often misapplied
. A rewards program needs to share value in proportion to the value th
e customers' loyalty creates for the company. A company must first mak
e sure that its rewards align with company capabilities, then take int
o account the five elements that determine value to a customer: cash v
alue, choice, aspirational value, relevance, and convenience. Any comp
any can attain access to the full set of capabilities. Some businesses
choose to band together with others in a rewards network. Louise O'Br
ien and Charles Tones, developers of the customer loyalty practice at
Bain and Company, explore principles that companies should keep in min
d when trying to develop effective value-sharing programs: All custome
rs are not equal; value created must exceed value delivered customer b
ehavior must drive value sharing; long-term perspective is critical; o
ffers must target attractive customers. The authors detail the ways Am
erican Express, General Motors, State Farm, Neiman Marcus, Saks Fifth
Avenue, MCI, Air Miles, and others are building customer loyalty. The
full potential of value sharing through rewards is realized only when
customers change their habits to become sustainably loyal. And designi
ng effective rewards programs often requires overcoming barriers raise
d by functional departments. Senior managers must agree that loyalty p
ays and be unrelenting about focusing their organizations and all thei
r marketing programs on the goals and measures that will develop custo
mer loyalty.