Tv. Murphy et al., FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH UNNECESSARY IMMUNIZATION GIVEN TO CHILDREN, The Pediatric infectious disease journal, 16(1), 1997, pp. 47-52
Objective. To determine the factors associated with unnecessary immuni
zation during the preschool years. Methods. Children were selected fro
m birth certificates and their parents were interviewed to identify al
l immunizations to 72 months of age. The immunizations were verified.
Results. Of 187 children studied 34 (18%) received unnecessary immuniz
ation. Unnecessary immunization was strongly associated with ever rece
iving immunization in a large system of public clinics (designated ''P
ublic A'') (33%) compared with other providers (5%) (P < 0.00001). Amo
ng children immunized in Public A, unnecessary immunization was associ
ated with the parent having an incomplete or no copy of the child's im
munization record (P = 0.007) and with not being up to date for immuni
zations at 24 months of age (P = 0.04). Complete documentation of immu
nizations either in the Public A record or in the parent's copy of the
record was associated with a 4% rate of unnecessary immunization; inc
omplete or no documentation in both the Public A and the parentis reco
rd was associated with a 45% rate of unnecessary immunization (P = 0.0
01). Conclusion. Access to a complete immunization record, be it the p
rovider's, the parent's or ideally both, decreases substantially a chi
ld's risk of unnecessary immunization.